[Rhodes22-list] Political: Voter Suppression

[Lowe, Rob]

Ben,
There were similar reports during last presidential election cycle.  As
elections are overseen by local election officials, there is a great
opportunity for abuse.  Interesting, you rarely hear of Democratic
election officials being accused of voter suppression tactics.  There
needs to be a systematic method for purging voters from voter lists.  -
rob


-----Original Message-----
From: rhodes22-list-bounces at rhodes22.org
[mailto:rhodes22-list-bounces at rhodes22.org] On Behalf Of Ben Cittadino
Sent: Monday, October 27, 2008 10:38 AM
To: rhodes22-list at rhodes22.org
Subject: [Rhodes22-list] Political: Voter Suppression


This is a disturbing report. For all the "voter fraud" charges on the
one
hand, there seem to be "voter suppression" charges on the other. 

ATLANTA, Georgia (CNN) -- College senior Kyla Berry was looking forward
to
voting in her first presidential election, even carrying her voter
registration card in her wallet.


"Vote suppression is real. It does sometimes happen," said Daniel P.
Tokaji,
a law professor at Ohio State University.

 But about two weeks ago, Berry got disturbing news from local election
officials.

"This office has received notification from the state of Georgia
indicating
that you are not a citizen of the United States and therefore, not
eligible
to vote," a letter from the Fulton County Department of Registration and
Elections said.

But Berry is a U.S. citizen, born in Boston, Massachusetts. She has a
passport and a birth certificate to prove it.  

The letter, which was dated October 2, gave her a week from the time it
was
dated to prove her citizenship. There was a problem, though -- the
letter
was postmarked October 9.

"It was the most bizarre thing. I immediately called my mother and asked
her
to send me my birth certificate, and then I was like, 'It's too late,
apparently,' " Berry said.

Berry is one of more than 50,000 registered Georgia voters who have been
"flagged" because of a computer mismatch in their personal
identification
information. At least 4,500 of those people are having their citizenship
questioned and the burden is on them to prove eligibility to vote.

Experts say lists of people with mismatches are often systematically
cut, or
"purged," from voter rolls.

It's a scenario that's being repeated all across the country, with cases
like Berry's raising fears of potential vote suppression in crucial
swing
states.

"What most people don't know is that every year, elections officials
strike
millions of names from the voter rolls using processes that are secret,
prone to error and vulnerable to manipulation," said Wendy Weiser, an
elections expert with New York University's Brennan Center for Justi 

"That means that lots and lots of eligible voters could get knocked off
the
voter rolls without any notice and, in many cases, without any
opportunity
to correct it before Election Day."

Weiser acknowledged that "purging done well and with proper
accountability"
is necessary to remove people who have died or moved out of state.

"But the problem is it's not necessary to do inaccurate purges that
catch up
thousands of eligible voters without any notice or any opportunity to
fix it
before Election Day and really without any public scrutiny at all," she
said.

Such allegations have flared up across the United States during this
election cycle, most notably in Ohio, where a recent lawsuit has already
gone to the U.S. Supreme Court.

There, the state Republican Party sued Ohio's Democratic secretary of
state
in an effort to make her generate a list of people who had mismatched
information. But Secretary of State Jennifer Brunner said generating
such a
list would create numerous problems too close to the election and
possibly
disenfranchise hundreds of thousands of voters.

The Supreme Court last week ruled against the GOP on appeal of a lower
court
order directing Brunner to prepare the list.

In Florida, election officials found that 75 percent of about 20,000
voter
registration applications from a three-week period in September were
mismatched due to typographical and administrative errors. Florida's
Republican secretary of state ordered the computer match system
implemented
in early September.

In Wisconsin, Republican Attorney General J.B. Van Hollen sued the
state's
election board after it voted against a proposal to implement a
"no-match"
policy. The board conducted an audit of its voter rolls and found a 22
percent match failure rate -- including for four of the six members of
the
board.

The Brennan Center has also documented cases across the country of
possible
illegal purging, impediments to college student voting and difficulties
accessing voter registration.

A lawsuit has been filed over Georgia's mismatch system, and the state
is
also under fire for requesting Social Security records for verification
checks on about 2 million voters -- more requests than any other state.

One of the lawyers involved in the lawsuit says Georgia is violating a
federal law that prohibits widespread voter purges within 90 days of the
election, arguing that the letters were sent out too close to the
election
date.

"They are systematically using these lists and matching them and using
those
matches to send these letters out to voters," said McDonald, director of
the
ACLU Voting Rights Project in Georgia. 

"It's not, you know, an individualized notion of people maybe not being
citizens or not being residents. They're using a systematic purging
procedure that's expressly prohibited by federal laws."

Asked if he believed that eligible voters were purged in Georgia,
McDonald
said, "If people who are properly eligible, are getting improperly
challenged and purged, the answer would be 'Yes,' " he said.

Elise Shore, regional counsel for the Mexican American Legal Defense and
Educational Fund, said letters like those sent to Berry appear to
violate
two federal laws against voter purging within 90 days of the election.

"People are being targeted, and people are being told they are
non-citizens,
including both naturalized citizens and U.S.-born citizens," said Shore,
another plaintiff in the Georgia lawsuit. "They're being told they're
not
eligible to vote, based on information in a database that hasn't been
checked and approved by the Department of Justice, and that we know has
flaws in it."

Georgia's Secretary of State Karen Handel, a Republican who began
working on
purging voter rolls since she was elected in 2006, said that won't
happen.
If there are errors, she said, there is still plenty of time to resolve
the
problems.

Handel says she is not worried the verification process will prevent
eligible voters from casting a ballot.

"In this state and all states, there's a process to ensure that a voter
who
comes in -- even if there's a question about their status -- that they
will
vote either provisional or challenge ballot, which is a paper ballot,"
she
said.

"So then the voter has ample opportunity to clarify any issues or
address
them," Handel added. "And I think that's a really important process."

Handel denied the efforts to verify the vote are suppression.

"This is about ensuring the integrity of our elections," she said. "It
is
imperative to have checks and balances on the front end, during the
processes and on the back end. That's what the verification process is
about."

So someone like Kyla Berry will be allowed to cast a provisional ballot
when
she votes, but it's up to county election officials whether those
ballots
would actually count.


Berry says she will try to vote, but she's not confident it will count.

"I know this happens, but I cannot believe it's happening to me," she
said.
"If I weren't allowed to vote, I would just feel like that would be ...
like
the worst thing ever -- a travesty." 
 
Ben C.

-- 
View this message in context:
http://www.nabble.com/Political%3A-Voter-Suppression-tp20188986p20188986
.html
Sent from the Rhodes 22 mailing list archive at Nabble.com.

__________________________________________________
To subscribe/unsubscribe or for help with using the mailing list go to
http://www.rhodes22.org/list
__________________________________________________